Before a firm spends on ads, SEO or a redesign, its website should pass fifteen checks in six areas: being found on Google, being readable by AI assistants, phone speed, intake, reviews and trust. Most can be checked in about a minute with the free law firm website audit. The rest take a partner ten minutes with a phone in hand.
The order below follows the money. The checks near the top decide whether people find the firm at all. The checks near the bottom decide whether the people who find it get in touch.
At a glance
- Audit the homepage and your highest-value practice page. They are judged separately.
- Run the checks on a phone. Google judges the phone version of a site, and so do many prospective clients.
- Intake details matter as much as rankings. A firm can rank well and lose the client at the contact step.
- This is a marketing check, not a compliance review. Your state bar's advertising rules still apply.
Can prospective clients find the firm on Google?
1. Each page says what it is about, and where
The page title and main heading should name the practice area and the city or region served, in the words a client would use. "Personal injury lawyer in San Diego" is clear to a person and to a search engine. "Welcome to our firm" is not.
2. Every practice area has its own page
One page that lists eight practice areas gives Google nothing specific to show for any of them. A separate page for each, with real detail, does. Our guide to practice area page structure covers what belongs on one.
3. The pages are allowed to be indexed
A setting left over from a redesign can ask Google not to list a page. It is easy to miss, because nothing on the page looks wrong. See why a website does not show up on Google.
4. The firm is described in structured data
Structured data is a short block of code that states, in a format machines read reliably, that this is a law firm, where it is, what it practices and who its attorneys are. See schema markup for law firms.
Can AI assistants read and describe the firm?
5. AI crawlers are allowed in
People now ask ChatGPT, Claude and Perplexity which lawyer to call. Those assistants can only describe a firm accurately if their crawlers may read its site, and some sites block them without anyone having decided to. See whether ChatGPT can see your website.
6. Client questions are answered in plain words
Pages that put the question a client would ask in a heading, and answer it in the first sentence underneath, are easier for both Google and AI assistants to quote. A heading such as "How long do I have to file a claim?" followed by a direct answer does more than a paragraph about the firm's dedication.
7. Attorneys are named, with credentials
Legal information can affect someone's money and freedom, and Google's guidance holds that kind of content to a higher standard of trust. Each attorney should have a page with their name, bar admissions, education and the matters they handle.
Does the site load quickly on a phone?
8. The phone speed score is in the good range
Google's phone test scores a page from 0 to 100, and 90 or more counts as good. On firm sites the usual causes of a low score are a large photo or video at the top and chat or tracking scripts. The causes of a slow phone site are a short list.
9. Nothing covers the page when it opens
A chat window, a pop-up and a cookie notice opening at once on a small screen hide the very thing the visitor came to read. Let the page show first.
Is it easy to contact the firm?
10. The phone number can be tapped
The number should sit at the top of every page and start a call when touched. A number that is part of an image, or that has to be copied by hand, costs calls.
11. There is a short form on the page
Someone reading about a custody dispute at eleven at night is not going to call. A short form on the page itself, asking for a name, a phone number or email and one line about the matter, lets them reach out when they are ready. A form that lives only on a separate contact page loses people at the extra click.
12. The next step is stated
Say what is on offer and what happens next: whether the first consultation is free, how soon someone will reply, and whether the firm takes texts. If the consultation is free, say so beside every contact button. More in why a website gets visitors but no calls.
Do reviews and proof show up?
13. Real client reviews are on the site, with a link to the source
Show reviews in the client's own words and link to the profile where they were left, so a visitor can verify them. Testimonials are a regulated area for lawyers. The ABA's Model Rule 7.1 bars false or misleading statements about a lawyer's services, and each state sets its own rules. California's are in Chapter 7 of its Rules of Professional Conduct. Check your own state bar's rules before publishing results or testimonials.
14. Results and recognition are real and current
Case results, awards, memberships and press mentions build confidence only when a visitor can check them. Link to the source where you can, date them, and remove anything that has lapsed.
Does the site look like a real, accountable firm?
15. The basics of trust are in place
A secure connection, an about page, an office location or service area, a privacy policy, the disclaimers your state requires, and contact details that match the firm's Google Business Profile exactly. Each is small. Together they let a stranger, a search engine or an AI assistant confirm that the firm is what it says it is. More in website trust signals.
How do you run the checklist in a minute?
The free law firm website audit runs most of these checks automatically. Enter the address of a page, and it scores six areas, lists what is missing in order of impact, and gives a 90-day plan. Run it on the homepage first, then on the practice page that brings in your most valuable matters, because each page is judged alone.
What it cannot do is judge the firm's standing outside its own website: where it ranks against competing firms, or whether AI assistants name it when asked. That is the work of a manual audit, which you can request on the audit page. For the full picture of what we do for firms, see marketing for law firms.
Frequently asked questions
The homepage, then the practice area page that brings in your most valuable matters. Each page is scored separately, so a strong homepage does not tell you how a practice page is doing.
No. It is a marketing and technical check. Advertising rules are set by each state bar, and the firm remains responsible for what it publishes. Treat any finding about reviews, results or claims as a prompt to check your state's rules.
After any redesign, platform change or new plugin, and otherwise about once a quarter. Most problems are introduced by changes, not by time.
Yes. An independent check takes a minute and shows whether the basics are in place. If it turns up gaps, it gives you specific questions to put to the agency.
As a rule of thumb, 80 or above overall, with no single area under 60. A low score in lead capture or speed is worth fixing first, because those lose clients who have already found you.